What are private debt investments?
Private debt investments / private credit investments involves investors providing funds to private businesses or in some instances to publicly traded businesses, where the debt itself (security) can’t be publicly traded. This can occur directly between investors and private businesses, or via investors investing into their money into a managed fund with an investment manager that then loans these funds out.
By their nature private debt investments are generally speaking illiquid, because they can't be easily transferred from one party to another, like publicly traded corporate debt or government bonds.
There are many subcategories of private debt investments and there are many financial products. Private debt investments can have a range of different types of security, from mortgage backed property, loan book backed, corporate guarantees and alternative assets. Picking the right type of private debt investments that is right for you, is critical to your investment goals.
At Royce Stone Capital we specialise in direct lending private debt investments that are mortgaged backed.
What is private credit?
Private credit investments are a subcategory of private debt investments. The term private credit investments is often used interchangeably with private debt investments. However, in our perspective, private credit focuses directly more so on funding to do with corporate facilities.
Typically, private credit in our eyes and that of Deutsche Bank, are transactions where private credit is where a corporate loan funded by investors is being given to a mid tier company. Additionally, we believe any facility where a loan book is being financed, such as a warehouse facility also belongs in this subcategory.
Private corporate credit can have a senior debt position, or it can be a subordinated debt position, with fixed or floating returns.
What are the risks of private debt investments?
As with all investments, there are risk and private debt investments are not immune but they are safer than many equity investments. Broadly speaking the below are the main risk involved with private debt and how we mitigate for these at RSC.
Investment manager risk
If you are investing your money into a private debt fund, then the performance of that fund is subject to the decisions made by the investment manager. Just because the fund says it will only lend to a 70% LVR of a property, does not mean the actual loan is 70% of the property value. As some investment managers can vary the way in which a property is valued, to make the valuation fit the requirements of the fund mandate!
Another issue with private debt funds and private credit funds, is investment managers may use their fund as security to take a loan. In other words they may provide the fund itself and the investors capital as security for a loan that the fund is taking to leverage its loan book. Once again at RSC because we don't run a fund, this is not an issue you will ever have to face!
At RSC, as an investor funder in our direct lending products, you make the decision! All information is presented to you, with our view, but you ultimately are the decision maker, and you can determine the level of DD you want done to your satisfaction!
Counter party risk
One of key risk with private debt investments, is the risk of that the borrower, the contractually obligated party does not fulfill their obligations and commitments under the loan agreement. This can include not repaying the loan on time, not paying interest on time, taking out other loan facilities beyond what is permitted or altering the underlying physical security.
With RSC direct lending investments borrowers as part of their signed legal obligations have a number legal obligations that they are contractually bound to. To ensure these borrowers honour these agreements borrowers must provide security for the transactions they enter into.
In most cases it is a first or second mortgage over property, which the lender can then enforce against and have sold, with additionally penalties going to the lender. Secondly borrowers must provide a personal guarantee. This means any assets held in their personal name can be claimed against, in the event of non-payment. Directors also leave themselves open to being made bankrupt and being prevented from being directors in future, if they are unable to repay all funds owed to the lender.
What this means, is that RSC investor funders, have a number points of recourse and security, by which to enforce their rights in the events borrowers default against terms. Giving our investor funders confidence, to move ahead with transactions, whilst ensuring their principal has security.
Valuation risk, LVR, property value over time:
One of the key risks with private debt investments, in specific mortgage backed lending, is the value of the underlying property asset that is being provided as security!
Valuation
When it comes to property security, a number of things need to be considered. What is the quality of the valuer? Is the valuation based on the as is current value? What would the property be worth in a fire sale scenario? is the valuation based on the site with permit values included, and if so, is that project still feasible, as the feasibility will determine the inherit permit value.
At RSC we do our own internal valuations and speak to a number of parties to determine the fire sale value of an asset. If we are in doubt or unsure, or at the request of our funders if neither us nor them can determine the value of the asset, we will engage a third party to do a valuation.
LVR and property liquidity
The type of property will also determine the loan LVR. A loan against a residential property in a major city can afford a 80% LVR, but a residential property in a regional town centre may only attract a 60% LVR. Similarly, a commercial property may attract a 75% LVR in a metropolitan city, but a piece of land that is yet to be rezoned may only attract a 60% LVR.
The LVR has several factors that come into consideration, the main one being the liquidity of an asset! The higher its liquidity, the higher an LVR can go. The lower the liquidity of an asset, the lower the LVR must be to compensate the investor / funder for any financial inconvenience caused, so the funder can be reimbursed.
Liquidity risk of private debt investments
By their nature private debt investments are not as liquid as publicly traded corporate bonds or government debt. This means that once an investor enters a private debt transaction, it is harder for them to sell the investment to another party. Because of this inconvenience investors are rewarded with an illiquidity premium.
In the case of mortgage-backed direct lending that we do at RSC, liquidity for investors comes via one of four ways.
- The borrower refinances their debt with another party, on maturity.
- The borrower repays the loan on maturity.
- The asset is sold by the investor / funder, due to the borrower being in default.
- The investor / funder can sell the loan contract to another lender (speak to us about how this is done.)
Who manages my money with a RSC private debt investment?
The role of RSC is to originate loans and to help with the loan management process. From start to finish, all funds are managed by you the investor / funder. We do not manage your money!
From when the loan is established, funds are transferred from your account to your solicitors account, who ensures all documentation is in order. Once the loan docs are signed to the satisfaction of your lawyer, and the mortgage registered. Funds are then transferred from your lawyer’s trust account to the borrowers lawyer’s trust account.
In the instance where interest is paid monthly. It is either paid directly to your nominated bank account or to your solicitor’s trust account.
RSC can help with loan management administration and certain communications with the borrower. But all decisions are ultimately made by you.